Desk Tabletops: Melamine, Veneer, Solid Wood or Bamboo?

The Comfortly TeamUpdated 7 min read

In short

For a work desk or an electric standing desk, an 18 mm melamine tabletop is the best value. It resists scratches and stains, is easy to clean and is relatively light, which leaves more lifting capacity for your equipment. Veneer gives you the look of real wood at a mid-range price, but it is more delicate. Solid wood and bamboo are the choice if you want a natural material you can sand and refinish, but they are heavier and more expensive. Your equipment sets the size: 140×70 cm for two monitors, 160×80 cm or larger for two large monitors or three.

Oak-finish computer desk tabletop with rounded corners and a cable grommet

Materials compared: melamine, veneer, solid wood and bamboo

A "wooden tabletop" can mean four very different things. The material decides how long the tabletop will last, how much weight it puts on the frame and how much it will cost:

Desk tabletop materials compared
Melamine on engineered woodVeneerSolid wood (oak, walnut)Bamboo
What it isAn engineered wood board with a hard decorative coatingA thin layer of real wood glued onto a boardWood staves glued into a single panelCompressed, glued bamboo strips
Scratch resistanceHighMediumMedium, depending on the wood type and finishHigh
Water resistanceGood on the surface. Sensitive at the edges if the edge banding is damagedSensitive to water marksGood with oil or lacquerGood with a suitable finish
CareWipe with a damp clothGentle cleaning, no abrasive productsOil or refresh the lacquer occasionallyOil occasionally
Can be sanded and refinishedNoVery littleYes, several timesYes
WeightRelatively lightLight to mediumHeavyHeavy
Relative priceLowMediumHigh to very highMedium to high

What about "oak tabletops" and "walnut tabletops"? In most stores, ours included, the oak and walnut finishes on computer desk tops are a wood-grain melamine coating. You get the look of wood with the durability of melamine, at a much lower price than solid wood. A solid oak tabletop is a different product: much heavier, and several times more expensive.

18 mm melamine tabletops: what you get with ours

  • Material: engineered wood with a scratch- and stain-resistant melamine coating, 1.8 cm thick.
  • Finishing: rounded corners and a cable grommet with a cover. OSHA recommends a desk with rounded edges, so your forearms don't rest on a sharp edge.
  • No pre-drilled holes: the tabletop is reversible and fits any type of legs or frame. When you assemble it, you decide whether the cable grommet goes on the right or the left.
  • Sizes: 120×60, 140×70, 160×80 and 180×80 cm.
Rounded corner of a walnut-finish desk tabletop
A rounded corner with matching walnut edge banding.

Which size to choose, and how much it weighs

The equipment on your desk sets the size. Weight matters especially on an electric desk, because it counts toward the frame's lifting capacity:

Desk tabletop sizes: use, weight and compatible frames
SizeWhat fitsEstimated weight (18 mm melamine)Compatible frames
120×60 cmA laptop and a monitorAbout 10 kgS1, S2, Mars legs
140×70 cmTwo 24-inch monitors, or a large monitor and a laptopAbout 13 kgS1, S2, Mars legs
160×80 cmTwo 27-inch monitors, or an ultrawide monitor with room to writeAbout 17 kgS1, S2, Mars legs
180×80 cmThree monitors, video editing or gamingAbout 19 kgS1, S2, Mars legs

Weights are calculated from the typical density of engineered wood. A 2.5 cm solid wood or bamboo tabletop in 160×80 weighs about 23-25 kg.

Depth matters too: OSHA recommends placing your monitor at least 50 cm from your eyes. With a keyboard in front of the monitor, a depth of 60 cm is enough for a monitor up to 24 inches, and for a 27-inch monitor or larger, a depth of 70-80 cm is better.

Want to check the right desk height too? Our desk height calculator works it out based on your height.

A tabletop on an electric frame: weight, thickness and width

  • Weight: the tabletop counts toward the lifting capacity. On the S1, which lifts up to 80 kg, a 160×80 tabletop (about 17 kg) leaves more than 60 kg for two or three monitors, a computer and speakers. The S2 lifts up to 120 kg and can also take a heavy solid wood tabletop and plenty of equipment.
  • Width: the S1 frame and Mars legs fit tabletops 100-180 cm wide, and the S2 frame fits tabletops up to 2.2 m wide.
  • Thickness: 18 mm or more allows the frame to be screwed in securely. In a thinner tabletop, the screws may poke through or work loose.
  • Assembly: lay the tabletop upside down on a soft surface, center the frame on it and screw it in with a drill driver. With solid wood and bamboo, drill a thin pilot hole first.
  • Cable grommet: place it on the side where your computer sits, and leave the cables enough slack for the full standing height.

Finishes: White, Oak, Light Oak, Walnut and Black

Available finishes by tabletop size
SizeFinishes
120×60 cmWhite, Oak
140×70 cmWhite, Oak, Light Oak, Walnut, Black
160×80 cmWhite, Oak, Light Oak, Walnut
180×80 cmOak

Availability of each finish is kept up to date on the product page.

  • White: brightens a small room and pairs well with white legs. A clean look, but it shows stains more.
  • Oak and Light Oak: the most popular finishes for the home. They hide fingerprints and light scratches.
  • Walnut: a dark, warm tone that looks great with black legs.
  • Black: a modern look for a home office or gaming room. Dust shows more on it.

When a solid wood or bamboo tabletop is worth it

Solid wood and bamboo suit you if you want a natural material, a warm feel and a tabletop you can sand and refinish years later. The downside is weight and price: a 160×80 tabletop that is 2.5 cm thick weighs about 23-25 kg, so it is best paired with a dual-motor frame.

Our solid wood tabletop comes as part of the S2 Bamboo desk: a 2.5 cm solid bamboo tabletop, polished with rounded corners, in 160×80 or 180×80 cm, on a dual-motor frame that lifts up to 120 kg.

Frequently asked questions

For most desks, and especially for an electric standing desk, melamine is better value: it resists scratches and stains, is easy to clean, is relatively light and costs less. Solid wood suits you if you want a natural material you can sand and refinish, and you are willing to pay more and account for the extra weight.